Step 5: What to Send After They Opt In


Hey Reader,

So someone downloads your lead magnet. Nice!

Now what?

You could just say thanks, deliver the resource, and disappear for a few weeks…
Or, you could keep the momentum going, build a relationship, and guide them toward your next offer or opportunity.

Let’s go with the second option. Here's how to do it.

Start with a short welcome sequence
This can be 3–5 emails sent over a few days after someone joins your list via downloading your lead magnet.

The goal with this sequence is to:

  • Help them get to know you.
  • Reinforce the value you bring, and the value they got from the lead magnet.
  • Set expectations for future emails - How often you send, what kind of info you share, etc.
  • Invite them to take a next step. This could be downloading another lead magnet, replying to the email with an answer to a question, or even buying (or taking a step closer to buying) whatever your offer is.

A simple welcome sequence might look like this:

Email 1: Deliver the lead magnet

  • Friendly, short, helpful. (We already covered this in Email 4.)
  • Send immediately after they opt-in. It's primary focus is getting them the lead magnet.

Email 2: Who you are + why you do this work

  • Share a little of your story. Keep it human and real. This builds connection fast.
  • Send 1 day after the lead magnet delivery.

Email 3: What they can expect from your emails

  • How often will you email them? What kind of content will you share? Let them know.
  • Send this 1-2 days after email 2.

Email 4: Share a quick win

  • Send a valuable tip, a helpful resource, or a story that connects with their challenges.
  • Prove you're worth staying subscribed to.
  • Send 1-2 days after email 3.

Email 5: Invite them to a next step

  • This could be a paid product or service, a free call, a video, or another great piece of content.
  • Just keep the CTA simple and relevant.
  • Send 1-2 days after email 4

Even if you’re not ready to build out the entire welcome sequence yet, just set one follow-up email to send after the lead magnet delivery email. Even one email can make an impact.

Keep all your emails conversational. Focus on building trust. And always aim to provide value before asking for anything.

It's okay to ask for the sale, but you need to build trust first, last, and always.

That’s it! You can get this lead magnet launched!

Over the last 5 weeks, we have come up with an idea, decided on a format, created our lead magnet, set it up to deliver automatically, and started to build a welcome sequence.

Put it all together and get it out there!

Remember, you're lead magnet isn't just some free thing you give to people...it's the start of a relationship with people.

Now you’ve got the tools to make that relationship meaningful and strategic.

Let me know if you want help brainstorming your welcome sequence or next steps.

You’re doing the work. I see it. Keep going.

I appreciate you.

~ Jeff

I appreciate you.

Jeff Gargas

COO / Co-Founder, Teach Better Team

P.S. When you're ready, here's how I can help:


Did you get to here?

I wanted to test something out this week. If you've read down to here and notice that a few things are missing, I'd love to know.

Hit 'reply' and let me know what part you wish would have been here:

  • What I'm Listening To
  • Things to Check Out
  • Content Creation Idea

2250 Lynnwood Drive, Stow, OH 44224
Unsubscribe · Preferences

EDUcreator Club Newsletter

Helping educators create and grow brands to promote a product or idea they want to share with others to better education. Tips, tricks, and resources for educators creating content and/or launching side hustles to share their passions.

Read more from EDUcreator Club Newsletter

Hey Reader, Quick question for you... If someone asked, “What do you offer?” could you answer clearly…in 2 sentences or less? If not, don’t worry. That’s what today's email is for. Here’s a simple formula I use (and teach) to write a clear, compelling offer description: Fill in the blanks: I help [who] with [what], so they can [what they get/why it matters]. Let’s say you’re offering a 60-minute virtual workshop on student engagement. You could say: I help middle school teachers reignite...

Hey Reader, You’ve got an offer idea. You’re feeling good. And then it hits you… “Wait. How much should I charge for this?” You don’t want to scare people away with a high price. But you also don’t want to undervalue your time and energy. Here’s a simple rule of thumb for pricing your first offer: Start with "Easy Yes" pricing. Your first goal isn’t to maximize revenue. It’s to get your first few sales, build momentum, and validate your idea. Here’s are a couple potential offers and how I...

Hey Reader, When you’re ready to start making money from your ideas, it’s tempting to jump into building a full-blown course or complicated membership. But your first offer doesn’t need to be big...or perfect. In fact, the simpler it is, the more likely you’ll actually launch it. With that in mind, here are 3 offers you can create (and sell!) this weekend: 1: A Paid Resource BundleTake your lead magnet and build on it. Add bonus templates, editable versions, lesson plans, walkthrough videos,...